Recap
“’Not properly human’: literary and cinematic narratives about human harvesting”, by Henriette Roos, discusses the effects of human harvesting through film and words. Although it doesn’t really pertain to the movie I chose to write about, “Seven Pounds”, it does raise many concerns about human harvesting. Human harvesting is basically when immigrants are brought into this country and they are completely used. When I say used, I mean they are not cared for properly or appreciated as they should be. They are paid less than anyone, and do the work that nobody will stand to do but them. Though that is an important topic, it isn’t the topic I should be talking about. The only quote that truly related to “Seven Pounds” (the first quote in the notes) shows that there is more than one mind that knows the value of an organ donor these days. The fact that the three candidates were competing for the most “heart-rending” story is almost a direct relation to the movie “Seven Pounds”, where Will Smith looks for the seven people with the best intentions and morals to give them his organs. That can raise many questions and thoughts about the movie as you watch it next. The rest of the essay was mostly about movies and texts that show the harms of human harvesting, which doesn’t relate to the movie.
Notes
“The Dutch media company Endemol, creators of the now international money-spinning show “Big Brother”, advertised a new production. A terminally ill cancer patient would decide on stage and before a worldwide audience which one of three desperate candidates could present the most heart-rending story and thus “win” her healthy kidney. That the show turned out to be a “hoax” aimed at raising awareness of donor shortage and recruiting potential donors, changed much of the initial outrage professed by other, less successful, television stations into disappointed complaints.”(1 Context and Concern)
This passage from the essay relates to “Seven Pounds” very well, as it shows how little people that are donating organs compared to the amount of people who truly need them. The fact that the three candidates were competing for the most “heart-rending” story is almost a direct relation to the movie “Seven Pounds”, where Will Smith looks for the seven people with the best intentions and morals to give them his organs.
“Recent court cases in South Africa involved doctors attached to a respected medical school, who formed an international syndicate trading in human kidneys; a new Maria in Egypt is turning that country into the regional hub for the human organ trade … the charges seem endless.” (Context and Concern)
This quote shows the varied people that are trying to help with organ donation to those in need, even opposing the laws of government if they must do so.
“the ancient acts of trading, robbing or killing to obtain the desired object seem more successful for the present. (Context and Concern)
This quote shows an obvious pessimistic view of our present way of dealing with organ trade coming from Henriette Roos.
“regarding someone else as not properly human, dehumanises us all.”
This shows that we cannot look down at others, as it stoops up lower than them.